If you've ever applied for an apartment, loan, or prepared for tax season, you've probably been asked for either a pay stub or a W-2 form. While both documents relate to your employment and income, they serve very different purposes and contain different information.
Understanding the difference between these two crucial documents can save you time, prevent confusion, and ensure you provide the right paperwork for each situation. Let's break down everything you need to know.
What Is a Pay Stub?
A pay stub (also called a paycheck stub, pay slip, or earnings statement) is a document you receive with every paycheck that details your earnings and deductions for that specific pay period.
Pay Stub Basics:
What's On a Pay Stub:
- • Employee and employer information
- • Pay period dates
- • Hours worked (for hourly employees)
- • Gross pay (before deductions)
- • Federal, state, and local taxes withheld
- • FICA (Social Security & Medicare) deductions
- • Other deductions (insurance, retirement, etc.)
- • Net pay (take-home amount)
- • Year-to-date (YTD) totals
What Is a W-2 Form?
A W-2 form (officially called "Wage and Tax Statement") is an IRS tax form that employers must send to employees and the IRS at the end of each tax year. It summarizes your total annual earnings and the taxes withheld over the entire year.
W-2 Basics:
What's On a W-2:
- • Employee's name, address, and Social Security number
- • Employer's name, address, and EIN (Employer ID Number)
- • Box 1: Total taxable wages for the year
- • Box 2: Total federal income tax withheld
- • Box 3: Social Security wages
- • Box 4: Social Security tax withheld
- • Box 5: Medicare wages and tips
- • Box 6: Medicare tax withheld
- • State and local tax information (Boxes 15-20)
- • Other compensation details (bonuses, retirement contributions, etc.)
Key Differences Explained
Pay Stub
Received with every paycheck:
- • Weekly: 52 pay stubs/year
- • Bi-weekly: 26 pay stubs/year
- • Semi-monthly: 24 pay stubs/year
- • Monthly: 12 pay stubs/year
W-2 Form
Received once per year:
- • Only 1 W-2 per employer per year
- • Must be sent by January 31st
- • Covers entire previous calendar year
- • If you change jobs, you get separate W-2s
Pay Stub
Proves current, ongoing income
- ✓ Verify accurate payment
- ✓ Track deductions and taxes
- ✓ Document current employment
- ✓ Apply for rentals/loans
- ✓ Budget planning
W-2 Form
Required for filing taxes
- ✓ File federal income tax return
- ✓ File state income tax return
- ✓ Verify annual earnings
- ✓ Apply for financial aid (FAFSA)
- ✓ Historical income verification
Pay Stub
Shows detailed breakdown per pay period:
- • Hours worked
- • Hourly rate or salary
- • Overtime calculations
- • Each individual deduction
- • Current period + YTD totals
- • Benefits contributions
W-2 Form
Shows annual summary only:
- • Total annual wages
- • Total taxes withheld
- • Social Security/Medicare totals
- • Retirement contributions
- • No breakdown by pay period
- • No hourly rate or hours
Pay Stub
Varies by state — Most states require employers to provide pay stubs, but requirements differ:
- • Some require printed copies
- • Some allow electronic access
- • A few states have no requirement
- • Content requirements vary
W-2 Form
Federally required — All employers must provide W-2s:
- • Required by IRS law
- • Must be sent by January 31st
- • Filed with federal government
- • Failure to provide = penalties
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Pay Stub | W-2 Form |
|---|---|---|
| Frequency | Every paycheck (12-52/year) | Once per year |
| Time Period Covered | One pay period (1-4 weeks) | Full calendar year |
| Issued By | Employer/payroll company | Employer (filed with IRS) |
| Legal Requirement | Varies by state | Federally mandated |
| Primary Purpose | Prove current income | File tax return |
| Shows Hours Worked | ✓ Yes (hourly employees) | ✗ No |
| Shows Pay Rate | ✓ Yes | ✗ No |
| Itemized Deductions | ✓ Yes (detailed breakdown) | ✗ No (annual totals only) |
| YTD Totals | ✓ Yes (running total) | ✓ Yes (final annual total) |
| IRS Form | ✗ No (internal document) | ✓ Yes (official tax form) |
| Deadline | With each paycheck | By January 31st |
| Can File Taxes With It? | ✗ No | ✓ Yes (required) |
| For Apartment Applications | ✓ Yes (preferred) | △ Sometimes accepted |
| Format | Varies by employer | Standardized IRS form |
When to Use Each Document
1Apartment/Rental Applications
Landlords want to see your current income. Provide your last 2-3 pay stubs to prove ongoing employment.
2Loan Pre-Approval
Mortgage and auto loan lenders typically request recent pay stubs (30-60 days) to verify current earnings.
3Credit Card Applications
Some credit card companies request pay stubs to verify income for high-limit cards.
4Child Support Calculations
Courts use recent pay stubs to calculate current income for child or spousal support.
5Personal Budgeting
Track your take-home pay, deductions, and ensure your employer is paying you correctly.
6Verifying Employer Payments
Compare pay stubs to your employment contract to ensure accurate hourly rates, overtime, and deductions.
1Filing Your Tax Return
Required to file federal and state income taxes. The IRS will not accept a pay stub for tax filing.
2FAFSA Applications
Financial aid applications for college require W-2 forms to verify family income from prior year.
3Mortgage Final Approval
Lenders request W-2s (usually last 2 years) for final approval to verify income history and stability.
4Social Security Benefits
SSA uses W-2s to calculate your benefits and verify your work history.
5Background Checks
Some employers request W-2s during background checks to verify previous employment and income.
6Immigration Applications
USCIS often requires W-2s to prove financial history and employment for visa and green card applications.
What Landlords Prefer (And Why)
🏠 Most landlords prefer PAY STUBS over W-2 forms
Why Landlords Want Recent Pay Stubs:
Proves Current Employment
A W-2 only shows you had income last year. A recent pay stub proves you're currently employed and earning money right now.
Shows Consistent Income
Multiple pay stubs (2-3 months) demonstrate regular, consistent paychecks—landlords want to see you can reliably pay rent each month.
More Recent Information
A W-2 could be 1-12 months old. Your income might have changed (promotion, job loss, raise). Pay stubs reflect your current financial situation.
Easier to Verify
Landlords can contact your current employer (listed on pay stub) to verify employment. A W-2 doesn't show if you still work there.
Standard Landlord Requirements:
- •Last 2-3 pay stubs (most common request)
- •Income must be 3x monthly rent (typical requirement)
- •Pay stubs must be recent (within 30-60 days)
- •May also request employment verification letter
What Lenders Require (The Full Picture)
Mortgage lenders, auto loan companies, and banks typically require BOTH pay stubs and W-2 forms for different purposes:
Recent Pay Stubs
Purpose: Verify current income
Typical Request: Last 30-60 days
- • Shows you're currently employed
- • Verifies stated income on application
- • Confirms recent pay rate
W-2 Forms
Purpose: Verify income history & stability
Typical Request: Last 1-2 years
- • Proves income stability over time
- • Verifies employment history
- • Cross-references with tax returns
For Mortgage Applications:
Lenders typically request:
- ✓ Most recent 2 pay stubs
- ✓ W-2 forms for the last 2 years
- ✓ Tax returns for the last 2 years
- ✓ Employment verification letter
- ✓ Bank statements (2-3 months)
Can You Use One Instead of the Other?
❌ NO
You cannot file your tax return with only pay stubs. The IRS requires a W-2 form. However, you can use your last pay stub of the year to estimate your taxes while waiting for your W-2 (which must be sent by January 31st).
△ MAYBE
Some landlords will accept a W-2, especially if combined with:
- Employment verification letter (proves you still work there)
- Bank statements showing regular deposits
- Offer letter showing current salary
However, most landlords strongly prefer recent pay stubs because they prove current income, not past income.
✓ Provide both when possible
For major applications (mortgages, large loans), having both documents ready gives the most complete picture of your financial situation:
- • Pay stubs = Current income & employment status
- • W-2 forms = Historical income & tax information
What If You're Self-Employed or a Freelancer?
Self-employed individuals, freelancers, gig workers, and small business owners don't receive traditional pay stubs or W-2 forms. Instead, you'll receive:
Instead of Pay Stubs:
- • Create your own pay stubs
- • Bank statements showing deposits
- • Profit & loss statements
- • Client invoices/contracts
Instead of W-2:
- • 1099 forms (from clients)
- • Tax returns (1040 + Schedule C)
- • Business tax returns
- • CPA letter verifying income
Frequently Asked Questions
Pay stubs are provided with every paycheck (weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly) and show earnings and deductions for that specific pay period. W-2 forms are provided once per year and summarize your total annual earnings and taxes withheld for the entire calendar year.
No, you cannot use a pay stub to file your tax return. The IRS requires a W-2 form for filing taxes. However, you can use your last pay stub of the year to estimate your taxes while waiting for your W-2, which employers must provide by January 31st.
Most landlords prefer recent pay stubs (last 2-3 months) because they show current, ongoing income. A W-2 only shows last year's earnings and doesn't prove you're currently employed. Pay stubs demonstrate active employment and consistent income.
Most landlords request your last 2-3 pay stubs (covering the most recent 1-3 months). This demonstrates consistent, current income and ongoing employment.
You'll receive a separate W-2 from each employer you worked for during the calendar year. If you had 3 jobs in one year, you'll receive 3 W-2 forms. You must include all W-2s when filing your taxes.
Yes, the year-to-date (YTD) totals on your final pay stub should closely match the figures on your W-2. Small differences may exist due to pre-tax deductions or timing, but gross wages and taxes should align. If there's a significant discrepancy, contact your HR department.
Self-employed individuals don't receive traditional pay stubs or W-2 forms. Instead, you can:
- • Create your own pay stubs to document income
- • Provide 1099 forms from clients
- • Show tax returns (1040 with Schedule C)
- • Provide bank statements showing deposits
- • Get a CPA letter verifying income
Generate professional pay stubs here for rental and loan applications.
Employers are required by federal law to send W-2 forms by January 31st each year. If you haven't received your W-2 by mid-February, contact your employer's HR or payroll department. If they don't respond, you can contact the IRS for assistance.
If you're self-employed or need to document your income, yes, you can create your own pay stubs as long as all information is accurate and truthful. Many self-employed individuals, freelancers, and small business owners create pay stubs to provide proof of income. Use a professional pay stub generator to ensure your stubs look professional and include all required information.
Need Professional Pay Stubs?
Whether you're applying for an apartment, getting a loan, or documenting your income, create accurate, professional pay stubs in minutes with our AI-powered generator.
Auto-Calculate All Taxes
Federal, state, FICA—all calculated automatically
Instant PDF Download
Professional format, ready to submit
Free Preview First
See before you buy
Related Articles
Complete guide to understanding every section of your pay stub.
Step-by-step guide to creating professional pay stubs.
What landlords look for and how to provide proper documentation.
How to prove income when you're your own boss.